Dr Lim Teck Ghee's of the Centre For Policy Initiatives directed an open letter to the 41 members of the various MACC Advisory Boards listed below. The letter is reproduced after the aforementioned list for non-subscribers of Malaysiakini where it was first posted.
Dr Lim's message to the 41 is basically one thing; "...do the right thing now-resign!"
Najib just announced a load of crap. Well, you want a Royal Commission? He gave you one! He also gave Teoh Beng Hock a magistrate! A mere magistrate for an inquest to determine how he died because his death does not deserve a Royal Commission...the RC is only to "...look into the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission's investigative procedures and to determine if there were any human right violations when Teoh Beng Hock was being interrogated."
The way I see it, the Cabinet is telling the 41 Advisory Board members they have not been "advising" properly so now we need a RC to do it for them! This particularly applies to the Operations Review Panel whose members are Dr Hadenan Abdul Jalil, Cecil Abraham, Nik Mohd Hasyudeen Yusoff, Walter Sandosam, Aminah Pit Abd Raman, Md Hamzah Md Kassim, and Dr Syed Noh Syed Ahmad. Were these people sent to HK to study the operations of the ICAC on tax payers' money? I sometimes wonder about people who consent to sit on "esteemed" advisory boards; are they there because of advocacy or merely to enhance their own standing.
As for the rabid dog called MACC? Looks like it is excusable to be misguided as to the investigative procedures used...after all most MACC officers were from the Police and they do not know better! What about the ICAC model that the MACC was supposed to follow? Read Citizen Nades here.
So? To the 41...you should have heeded the Dr's advice to resign. If you had done so before today's "Cabinet decision", you would still have walked away with honor. Now? Just go lah! The government has just labled you as being no different from the interrogators of TBH! The blood is on your hands too.
Anti-Corruption Advisory Board members
Abdul Hamid Mohamad
Amar Hamid Bugo
Dr Mohd Kamal Hassan
Mohamed Jawhar Hassan
Zaiton Zawiyah Puteh
Rashpal Singh Jeswant Singh
Yong Poh Kon
Dr Khoo Kay Kim
Chelvarajah Ramasamy Reddiar
Special committee on corruption
Mohd Radzi Sheikh Ahmad
Razali IbrahimAbdul Rahman Dahlan
Dr Tan Seng Giaw
Mohd Nor Abdullah
Muhammad Mohd Noor
Wan Abdul Wahab Abdullah
Chooi Mun Sau
Ravindran V Muthu
Operations review panel
Dr Hadenan Abdul Jalil
Nik Mohd Hasyudeen Yusoff
Aminah Pit Abd Raman
Md Hamzah Md Kassim
Dr Syed Noh Syed Ahmad
Corruption consultation and prevention panel
Dr Abdul Rahman Embong
Dr Zainal Abidin Abdul Majid
Wong Chun Wai
Prof Dr Ishak Tambi Kechik
Anis Yusal Yusoff
Robert Phang Miow Sin
Dr Lim Teck Ghee's Open Letter
Dear honourable men and women of the MACC advisory board, committee and panels,
A young and promising life was snuffed out too early and in the most unacceptable and suspicious of circumstances. It happened under your watch in the MACC.
I am not sure whether you are fully aware of the extent of public outrage that this tragic death has provoked. It is an outpouring which cuts across all groups and communities.
Much of this outpouring has been expressed over the blogs and websites. As usual, the mainstream media has not fully reported on the public revulsion and anger.
Just as important to note is that many Malaysians have lost faith in the MACC. It is not only the MACC that they have no confidence in. It is also the so-called watchdog advisory board, committees and panels - which you are all members of - that the public has expressed strong and negative feelings towards.
I myself have lost faith with the MACC and I must also declare here, with the advisory bodies which you are members of.
I know some of you personally – a few for many years now. Because you are honourable people and had good intentions when you agreed to serve, I strongly feel that the only way for you to redeem that lost honour and integrity when Teoh Beng Hock died under the custody of the MACC, is for you all to resign en bloc.
I know that it may prove difficult for you to resign all alone by yourself given the long and vindictive reach of our political authorities in dealing with individual dissent.
But as a group, that decision to resign should be a lot easier.Not only will you redeem that lost honour and integrity when you resign but your decision will – in my view – impact positively on the political consciousness of the nation at large.
With your decision, we can console ourselves that during this period of finger pointing and blame deflecting, there is a group of leaders that is willing to shoulder responsibility personally when things they are entrusted with go horribly wrong.
I hope you realise that it cannot be business as usual for the MACC advisory bodies. These bodies have lost that credibility and the public trust which is crucial in carrying out the mission of reform they were entrusted with.
For now, much of public perception is that the MACC's Advisory Board, Special Committee on Corruption, Complaints Committee, Operations Review Panel and the Corruption Consultation and Prevention Panel are merely serving as fig leaves attempting to cover up or justify the political agenda of an untrustworthy and disreputable agency. [See list above]
The longer you stay as members of the MACC advisory board, panels and committees, the more you risk your good name.
Retaining ties with MACC is to condone its unacceptable practices which have resulted in a tragic death. Decency calls that you consult your conscience and sever these ties immediately.Do the right thing now – please resign.